David Toscano

Commentary on Virginia and U.S. Politics & Culture

David Toscano
  • Home
  • About David
  • States Matter
  • The Legislative Years
    • General Assembly Updates
      • 2019 General Assembly Session
      • 2018 General Assembly Session
      • 2017 General Assembly Session
      • 2016 General Assembly Session
      • 2015 General Assembly Session
      • 2014 General Assembly Session
      • 2013 General Assembly Session
      • 2012 General Assembly Session
      • 2011 General Assembly Session
    • Press Releases
  • Search

The Politicization of Disaster Relief

September 9, 2011 by David Toscano

One of the reasons I entered politics was to help people in difficult circumstances.  Of all the times that we should marshal the resources of our communities and government, it should be during disasters.  Americans’ history of doing just that is now threatened by some conservative members of the U.S. Congress, including Virginia’s own Eric Cantor (R-7th).  Cantor, and his like-minded colleagues, want to make federal disaster aid contingent upon the enactment of cuts to other areas of the federal budget. This is unprecedented and inconsistent with how Americans have generally addressed disaster relief.

In Cantor’s case, it is also classic hypocrisy.

In August 2004, after Tropical Storm Gaston slammed into Central Virginia, Cantor sought the immediate assistance of the federal government in making more than $20 million in disaster aid available to his constituents. At that time, he also voted against an amendment to the supplemental bill for disaster aid that would have offset any increases in relief with budget cuts.   Now, in a complete reversal, he has argued that aid to Joplin, Missouri (devastated by a tornado in May 2011), assistance to Louisa County, Virginia (in the aftermath of the earthquake), and financial help to central and eastern Virginia (attempting to clean up in the aftermath of Irene), should not occur without comparable cuts in other federal government spending.

I hope that we will not abandon a time-honored principle that the federal government should run temporary deficits to address the immediate need brought on by natural disasters, and to repay those obligations, either by spending cuts or tax increases, over a longer period of time.   While Governor McDonnell has emphasized meeting the immediate need of Virginians in this post-disaster period, he has not been directly critical of Cantor’s statements in this area.   I trust that our Governor, and my colleagues in the Virginia House and Senate will join together in asserting that some measure of disaster relief is a “core service of government” that should not be held hostage to political ideology.

Share

Filed Under: General Assembly 2011

Topics

2016 presidential election (5) 2017 Virginia election (12) ABC law enforcement procedures (5) Adoption (3) Affordable Care Act - Virginia (21) Affordable Health Care (61) Anti-Discrimination (18) Charlottesville and Albemarle County (14) Charlottesville sidewalk funding program (3) Climate Change (12) Coal Tax Credits (14) DNA Database Expansion (11) Domestic Violence (6) Education (40) Educational reform (4) Environmental Protection (48) Equal Rights Amendment (4) Ethics reform (11) Financial exploitation of elderly (6) Foster Care (3) Gun Safety (34) Immigration (15) Job Creation (11) Judicial Appointments (8) K-12 Education funding (30) Legislative Redistricting (23) Medicaid expansion (52) Mental Health Policy (17) Pre-K Education Funding (7) Religious Freedom (4) Renewable Energy (31) Reproductive Choice (16) Same-Sex Marriage (4) Senator Creigh Deeds (3) Sexual Assault Policy (10) Special Session (11) State Employee Compensation (16) University of Virginia (7) Virginia budget (34) Virginia General Assembly Process (28) Virginia Health Insurance Marketplace (11) Virginia Higher Education Funding (19) Virginia Retirement System funding (5) Virginia transportation (12) Voting Access (12)

Join My Email List

Topics

2016 presidential election 2017 Virginia election ABC law enforcement procedures Adoption Affordable Care Act - Virginia Affordable Health Care Anti-Discrimination Charlottesville and Albemarle County Charlottesville sidewalk funding program Climate Change Coal Tax Credits DNA Database Expansion Domestic Violence Education Educational reform Environmental Protection Equal Rights Amendment Ethics reform Financial exploitation of elderly Foster Care Gun Safety Immigration Job Creation Judicial Appointments K-12 Education funding Legislative Redistricting Medicaid expansion Mental Health Policy Pre-K Education Funding Religious Freedom Renewable Energy Reproductive Choice Same-Sex Marriage Senator Creigh Deeds Sexual Assault Policy Special Session State Employee Compensation University of Virginia Virginia budget Virginia General Assembly Process Virginia Health Insurance Marketplace Virginia Higher Education Funding Virginia Retirement System funding Virginia transportation Voting Access

General Assembly Updates 2011-18

  • General Assembly 2018
  • General Assembly 2017
  • General Assembly 2016
  • General Assembly 2015
  • General Assembly 2014
  • General Assembly 2013
  • General Assembly 2012
  • General Assembly 2011

Contact Me

211 E. High Street
Charlottesville, VA 22902
Phone: 434-220-1660
Fax: 434-220-1677
david@davidtoscano.com

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Email list
Donate to the Virginia First PAC

Help me bring more common sense to the General Assembly by helping elect candidates that share our views in other districts across the Commonwealth. Make a contribution to my leadership PAC, Virginia First, where funds go directly to support candidates across the state. - David

Authorized by David Toscano
© Copyright 2006-20 · DavidToscano.com · All Rights Reserved ·